A fire went out from before gd and burned them up, and they died before gd. Torah parsha trumah assembly of calledout believers. Each year, when marking yom hashoah, i am shocked all over again by the unimaginable scale of the inhumanity and cruelty that befell our people. Torah parsha achareikedoshim assembly of calledout. This week at the jewish journal, parshat shemini is under discussion. The sons of aaron, nadav and avihu, took a pan, and placed fire within, and put incense upon the fire. His sons consumed by fire, aaron teaches us a silent.
Then, and only then, does moshes promise come true. For a deeper analysis of exactly which sin nadav and avihu died for and why, see the holy souls of nadav and avihu in garments of light. Aarons sons, nadav and avihu, each took his fire pan, placed fire on it, and then incense on it. Aaron, and moses, and miriam study verse in the updated bible version 1. On the day the mishkan was inaugurated see above, nadav and avihu, the sons of.
Rabbeynu bachya then continues to offer a kabbalistic reason. They were not like their father aaron who had to be persuaded to come close to the altar. Illustration of the sin of nadab and abihu, from a 1907 bible card. As nehama leibowitz reminds us regarding nadav and avihu, as regards to ourselves and as it is written, walk humbly with your god. After their death they returned again as an ibur a new higher soul coming into a person while he is still alive in pinchas son of elazar son of aharon hakohen for the purpose of correcting their soul nadav. The book of shemot exodus ends with the divine presence kavod filling the portable. Following the deaths of nadav and avihu, god warns against unauthorized entry into the holy. In the biblical books exodus, leviticus and numbers, nadab hebrew. Nadav and avihu, sons of aharon, took their incense pans and put fire and incense in them, and offered an unauthorized fire before gd, which he did not command them to do. In the biblical books exodus, leviticus and numbers, nadab. Efrat, israel one of the most problematic incidents in the entire bible is the traumatic death of aarons two sons, nadav and avihu, precisely at the zenith of the dedication of the sanctuary that was to be the province of the high priest, aaron.
Torah parsha achareikedoshim assembly of calledout believers. It begins by mentioning the two deaths the resolution of this question requires a comprehensive approach. This instruction was necessary in order to ensure that the incident involving nadav and avihu nadab and abihu would not happen again. They offered it before god, but it was unauthorized fire, which god had not instructed them to offer. About a hundred years before, at jonahs preaching, the ninevites repented, and were spared, yet, soon after, they became worse than ever. Yom kippur brings atonement and death of the righteous. Second, both were directly killed by yhvh for what seemed to be nothing more than mere breaches of protocol. The story of the blasphemer reflects the israelite concern lest god be profaned and the holiness of the camp be threatened. They decide to make an incense offering to god at an inappropriate time, presenting alien fire to god. Moses came and told the people all the words of the lordthe rehearsal of the foregoing laws and the ten commandments, together with the promises of special blessings in the event of their obedience, having drawn forth from the people a unanimous declaration of their consent, it was forthwith recorded as the conditions of the. The deaths of nadav and avihu, aarons sons, teach us the value and also danger of spontaneous religious expression. Commentaries, 23 vols by john calvin, matthew henrys commentary on the whole bible by matthew henry, the macarthur bible com.
Nadav and avihu were supposed to ignite the incense offering using the fire from the altar. At first glance, the noquestionsasked instant execution of these two groups seems hardly the behavior one would expect from a god who places such a high value on life, love, and mercy. Etz hayim torah and commentary, intro to haftorah for shmini, p. The zohar states that the two brothers were equal in. Designed for both jewish and nonjewish readers alike, the israel bible offers a unique commentary that seeks to explain gods focus on the land of israel alongside the original hebrew text, transliteration of select hebrew verses, and the new jewish publication society translation. Aarons two elder sons, nadav and avihu, offer a strange fire before g.
According to leviticus 10, they offered a sacrifice with foreign fire before the l ord, disobeying his instructions, and were. After their death they returned again as an ibur a new higher soul coming into a person while he is still alive in pinchas son of elazar son of aharon. Now aarons sons nadav and avihu each took his fire pan, put fire in it. The komarno rebbe in his hechal berecha notes that the souls of nadav and avihu left their bodies in a state of union with hashem and that they ascended above to cling to the tree of life. He states that nadav and avihu saw the descent of fire from heaven upon the altar. Knowing the context of chapter 16 is critical to fully understanding the teaching concerning yom kippur, the day of atonement. For many people the bible is a dusty old book with little relevance to their lives. Nadav and avihu, two of aarons four sons, were killed, the torah states, when they came close before god. If you wish to republish this article in a periodical, book, or website, please. We have learned, it is to teach that, just as yom kippur brings atonement to the jewish people, so the death of the righteous also brings atonement to the. This midrash on a verse in exodus is motivated by the need to explain a difficult passage in leviticus.
Later on, nadav and avihu also came from the good side of kayin, and this is the sod of the firstborn nadav and avihu bamidbar 3. True to torahs rigorous methodology, frame works moves from the dawn of history to the frontiers of contemporary thought, drawing deeply on the physical sciences and biology, on psychology, philosophy, literature and the arts. The eighth day and the sin of nadav and avihu vbm haretzion. In the beginning, kayin son of adam made an offering to hashem from the fruits of his labors. Thus, it is an allusion, for, kayin was the firstborn of adam harishon, the firstborn of history, and he reincarnated into nadav and avihu.
The time and place for spontaneity my jewish learning. This weeks parashah includes the tragic story of nadav and avihu, aarons two eldest. The five books of the torah contain just about every type of literature imaginable, including historical narrative, legal material, poems, and songs. How god was sanctified through nadav and avihus death. From the beginning of the book until the act of aarons two sons, the. Mar 04, 2017 alter of incense assembly of calledout believers bo called out believers cleansing exodus haftarah holy place intercession israel joseph josephs brothers judgments kedoshim lamp laver learn truth menorah messianic torah study mishpatim moses nadav and avihu offerings parashah parsha passover pastor isaac plagues priestly garments prophecy. They tried to attain closeness to the holy on their own initiative. It should have said velazar the firstborn nadav and avihu, elazar, with a vav. March 29, 2019by mychal springer commentary shemini shabbat parah. Therefore, although the actions of nadav and avihu were incorrect, their intentions were pure.
Separate your brother aaron and his sons from among the israelites, and bring them close to you so that aaron, and his sons, nadav, avihu, eleazar and ithamar, can become priests to me. Moses came and told the people all the words of the lordthe rehearsal of the foregoing laws and the ten commandments, together with the promises of special blessings in the event of their obedience, having drawn forth from the people a unanimous declaration of their consent, it was forthwith. Even for the torah the deaths of aarons sons nadav and avihu in this weeks parsha, shemini, are sensational. In this weeks parasha, shemini, we read of the sudden death of nadav and avihu, the sons of aaron. Only one person, the kohen gadol high priest, maybut once a year, on yom kippurenter the innermost chamber in the sanctuary to offer the sacred ketoret to god.
The smoke is dissipated to a degree by reading the haftara, relating the story of avinadavs son, uzza. This is what the kabbalists meant by saying that nadav and avihu divided binah from chochmah. The tragedies of jewish history have, unfortunately, introduced a slanted view of kiddush hashem, sanctification of gods name. The mysterious death of nadab and abihu chassidic masters. Commentaries tend to be more direct and express the commentators views regarding the book. Nadav and avihu erred by pursuing the spiritual joys of prophecy and inspiration in a form detached from torah and its practical teachings. The tragic death of aarons two elder sons, nadav and avihu. Nadav and avihu, sons of aharon, took their incense pans and put fire and incense in them, and offered an unauthorized fire before god, which he did not command them to do. Focusing on themes in key biblical texts good and evil, sexuality. In this weeks torah portion shemini nadav and avihu, the sons of aaron the high priest, each took his pan, put fire in it, placed incense upon it, and offered an alien fire before the lord, which he had not commanded them leviticus 10. The torah then goes on to describe the service performed by aaron on yom kippur. Jun 07, 2002 nadav and avihu, sons of aharon, took their incense pans and put fire and incense in them, and offered an unauthorized fire before gd, which he did not command them to do.
Trumah whiteboard in this study we see the beautiful symbolism within the. The torah states that they brought an incense offering that god had not commanded them leviticus 10. They reason that only the spiritual elite are privileged on this day to divine revelation, and the masses are not entitled to such direct contact with god. One commentary notes that it is never clear what nadav and avihu have done to draw divine punishment down upon themselves. The eighth day is a continuation of the revelation at mt. Nadav and avihu were not the first examples of presumptuousness in the torah. The trouble was that they believed they were great people. Apr 17, 2020 the torah column is supported by a generous donation from eve gordonramek. This idea predates the arizal, and is found in the zohar iii, 56b, which compares nadav and avihu to the two goats sacrificed on yom kippur. We are left to wonder at the mysterious nature of gods wrath. The story of nadav and avihu provides us with a good example of that.
Apr 08, 2010 nadav and avihu, sons of aharon, took their incense pans and put fire and incense in them, and offered an unauthorized fire before god, which he did not command them to do. Consecration of the, tabernacle, death of nadab and abihu, cloud the and pillars of fire. Veatah hakrev eleycha etaharon achicha veetbanav ito mitoch beney yisrael lechahanoli aharon nadav vaavihu elazar veitamar beney aharon. Veatah hakrev eleycha etaharon achicha veetbanav ito mitoch beney yisrael lechahanoli aharon nadav va avihu elazar veitamar beney aharon. Particularly effective are the chapters dealing with the binding of isaac by abraham and sibling rivalry in the stories of moses and his brother aaron, sister miriam and nephews nadav and avihu. Moses came and told the people all the words of the lord the rehearsal of the foregoing laws and the ten commandments, together with the promises of special blessings in the event of their obedience, having drawn forth from the people a unanimous declaration of their consent, it was forthwith recorded as the conditions of the. While it is important to know the plot of the torahs narratives, it is sometimes even more important to know its subplots. Rabbi sacks commentary on this weeks parsha limits shemini 5780 the story of nadav and avihu, aharons two eldest sons who died on the day the sanctuary was dedicated, is one of the most tragic in. You can find book commentaries in magazines and online.
We can see this also in the book torat cohanim that quotes. The real torahbased reason why god killed ananias and. From the author of the acclaimed patterns in time seriesa new series on parashas hashavua conceived and written for a general audience. This week we read about the aftermath of the most tragic event in the torah. Thus, among these three seminal medieval parshanim, three very different depictions of moses emerge in his attempt to rationalize the deaths of nadav and avihu to aaron, their father and his brother. And nadav and avihu, the sons of aaron, took each of them his. Following the seven days of their inauguration, aaron and his sons begin to officiate as kohanim priests. Sinai desert, 11 bce in shaar hagilgulim hakdamah 31 of the ari, rabbi yitzchak luria states that the souls of nadav and avihu came from a very high level of adam. Two of aarons sons, nadav and avihu, bring an unauthorized offering and. They offered a sacrifice with strange fire before gd, disobeying his instructions, and were immediately consumed by gds fire.
Rashi, in his literal understanding of moses citing gods communication, presents us with moses as prophet, as the mediator of gods direct word. May 01, 2017 following the deaths of nadav and avihu, god warns against unauthorized entry into the holy. In shaar hagilgulim hakdamah 31 of the ari, rabbi yitzchak luria states that the souls of nadav and avihu came from a very high level of adam. For the israeli singersongwriter, see avihu medina. At first glance, the noquestionsasked instant execution of these two groups seems hardly the behavior one would expect from a god who places such a. The meaning of nadav and avihus death 5769 torah mitzion. After the deaths of aarons sons, nadav and avihu lev 10.
Does god punish people who are close to him more harshly. A fire went out from before god and burned them up, and they died before god. Fire came forth from before god, and it consumed them, so that they died before god 10. Nadav and avihu did not devote themselves to the observance of mitzvos on the material plane. But the deity who lies at the heart of both stories, and several others in the torah and tanakh, remains a mystery. Mar 26, 2011 as nehama leibowitz reminds us regarding nadav and avihu, as regards to ourselves and as it is written, walk humbly with your god. Hebrew for gifted contribution or uplifted offering, is the nineteenth weekly torah portion in the annual jewish cycle of torah reading and tells of gods instructions to make the tabernacle and its furnishings. On the day the mishkan was inaugurated see above, nadav and avihu, the sons of aaron, took each of them his censer, and put fire in it, and put incense on it, and offered strange fire before gd, which he commanded them not. This foreshadows the next chapter, in which the heavenly fire takes the lives of aharons apparently errant sons nadav and avihu. Rabbi chaim ibn attar writes in his commentary, ohr hachaim, on this verse.
As to the nature and cause of the sin, the commentaries based on various midrashim differ. But for vistozky the bible is a living entity that can offer endless insights for its readers if they enter into dialogue with it in the manner of the ancient rabbis, whose midrash, or commentary, has accompanied it almost from its beginning. Thus, the story of nadav and avihus death is real on yom kippur, for not only does the yom kippur service bring atonement to the people, the death of tzaddikim brings atonement as well. The story of nadav and avihu is shrouded in the smoke of their incense. They did not endeavor to bring souls into this world.
255 423 37 1013 1171 1535 821 439 612 1039 1352 325 478 1109 827 1241 1373 338 851 1278 787 369 1298 1475 1178 130 1277 72 1172 1036 807 1450